There are a lot of bad websites out
there on the world wide web. I thought it was going to be difficult to decide
which website to write about until I stumbled across Liberty Van.
This website butchers web design
principles on so many levels, however I will limit this post to my top five
observations using the article 9 Essential Principles for Good Web Design.
These include spacing, typography, consistency, usability, and navigation.
1.
Spacing
– The first thing that caught my eye was the absolute lack of white space. This
page is just line after line of text crammed together with pictures. There is
not enough spacing between lines and in many cases lines of text overlap. There is also a complete lack of
padding. Lines of text run over on top
of pictures in several spots. By doing
this there is no logical flow to the page.
My eyes could not find a place to land and follow a path that made me want
to stay on the page and use it.
2.
Typography
– Coming from a television background this aspect of web design is always very
important to me. As a producer, I was
responsible to creating consistent easy to ready graphics. I counted at least five different fonts. There are at least 5 different colored
fonts. The blue text was very difficult
to read in places because it is placed on a blue background. Also the line lengths
are too long and the font styles, especially on small fonts were very difficult
to read.
3.
Consistency
– Or in this website’s case, a total lack of consistency. Most noticeably is the choice of many
different font styles, sizes and colors.
I think it is ok to uses different colors to highlight or group similar
thoughts or threads, but this website doesn’t do that at all. Most notably are the posted dates. Some are red, others blue, while even more
are black. Pick a color and stay with
it.
4.
Usability
– Some sense of organization would help this website with usability. It almost appears like when a thought or
event popped into the designers head they just added a new line to webpage. I think this page is dedicated to showing off
two vehicles that go out into the world to spread the word about the
constitution and liberty. There also
seems to be a heavy emphasis on pictures of the vehicles, but they are not
organized in a way that is very usable.
5.
Navigation – This sight could really benefit
from some simple navigation elements. A
top line menu with subjects of news, photos, events, and about us would make
this so much easier to navigate. Also
the use of some simple radio buttons would help greatly. One button that comes to mind immediately is
a Photo gallery button. Instead there
are hyperlinks throughout the page that say click here for photos, but they get
lost in the ocean of text.
I want to like this website, but I
can’t. I just don’t know where to start and even if I picked a starting point
there is no logical flow that makes me want to stay on the page for any length
of time to learn more about the Liberty and Freedom Vans.
Kevin,
ReplyDeleteThat is so funny I almost picked that one myself! I read through the site, and I am still not so sure what the point of the site even is. Your analogy is great, first the spacing, there literally is no white space, I am not really sure if there is
any free space, everything is covered. In the typography, the fonts are all over the place too, there is no consistency. It is funny, the van looks like the website. Everything is just jumbled together, it looks similar to the one I critiqued, it looks like someone just tried to type in everything they knew about the subject without any regard for themes or designated sections. The usability, was another issue, I am with you, I am really not sure what they are actually doing as an organization. The navigation is another story, there does not appear to be any type of indexes, or areas on context nothing, it is just all right there messed together! Great analogy!